×

Apple wins a partial victory over Patent Troll Optis

92% reliable
5 mins
30.5K views
iPhone
  • This stems from a long ongoing battle with a patent troll
  • The patent troll in question is called Optis
  • They plan to bring the case to the UK, one of Apple’s biggest markets

Apple just won a partial victory over Patent Troll Optis, due to a $506M award being reduced to $300M in a retrial over damages. However, billions of dollars may still be at play and Apple is willing to take some bold counter-measures.

But first, what or who is a patent troll? Patent trolls are companies dedicated to purchasing and trading patents where they don’t always have any involvement during development. In this case, Optis, a conglomerate consisting of PanOptis Patent Management, Optis Cellular and Unwired Planet, acquired 5 patents regarding LTE technologies from Samsung, LG and Panasonic. With the intent of charging bigger amounts than what they paid for to any company who used these essential, standard or required technologies on their products. These patents must be regulated by Fair, Reasonable, And Non-Discriminatory (FRAND) terms. However, there’s no tangible definition of what these terms actually mean. Which results in cases similar to this one, where a patent owner considers their terms FRAND, even when the licensee (Apple) doesn’t.

The court of the Eastern District of Texas is known for favoring patent trolls over licensees, which is why Optis chose to bring the case to this particular location. Apple’s argument was that these patents were not valid, but didn’t succeed in persuading the jury. This resulted in Optis being awarded $506 million over a year ago.

Apple appealed, and a federal judge dismissed the award, ruling a damages-only trial with the condition that Apple had indeed infringed the patents, but the exact award would be reviewed by a new jury. The jury, located in Marshall, Texas, announced Optis was owed this sum to cover past and future usage of the patents and technologies. But that’s not all. Optis chose to go after Apple for even larger sums that could cost billions of dollars to the Cupertino based company via a UK court battle. The Supreme Court of said country has recently ruled that any amount ruled would apply worldwide.

Apple said this is totally unreasonable, understandably so. Apple also claimed to leave the UK market altogether instead of paying an excessive sum. Apple’s lawyer insisted that this option was on the table, however the judge was skeptical. Mr. Justice Meade said: "There is no evidence it is even remotely possible Apple will leave the UK market" Marie Demetriou, Apple’s lawyer, answered: "I am not sure, that is right… Apple’s position is it should indeed be able to reflect on the terms and decide whether commercially it is right to accept them or to leave the UK market." There may be terms that are set by the court which are just commercially unacceptable."

This highlights the need for a more global and transparent patent reform. Overly broad and generic patents should be abolished and invalidated, they stifle innovation. Patent trolls should not be able to increase the cost of license fees for essential patents.

Recommended by the editors:

Thank you for visiting Apple Scoop! As a dedicated independent news organization, we strive to deliver the latest updates and in-depth journalism on everything Apple. Have insights or thoughts to share? Drop a comment below—our team actively engages with and responds to our community. Return to the home page.

Published to Apple Scoop on 16th August, 2021.
Stories related to iPhone

iPhone 17 Dummy Units Leaked in Hands-On Video

70% reliable9 mins

iPhone 16E: Features, Specs, Design, Release Date, and More

100% reliable20 mins

Apple Just Delayed Siri’s Smartest Feature—And It Might Never Arrive

68% reliable9 mins

Apple’s Foldable iPhone: Release Date, Design, Specs, Features, and More

64% reliable13 mins

Free Download: All iPhone 16E Stock Wallpapers in High Resolution

100% reliable6 mins

Top 100+ Free 4K Wallpapers for iPhone 16E

100% reliable6 mins

iPhone 16E Review: Great Performance, But Expect Some Trade-Offs

100% reliable10 mins

Apple’s Foldable iPhone: Why It’s Still Years Away

67% reliable9 mins

Price Hike Expected for iPhone 18 Pro

68% reliable8 mins

8 Reasons Why Apple Products Are So Expensive

100% reliable14 mins

iPhone 17 Air Rumored to Launch With These 8 New Features

67% reliable15 mins

Is 5G Coming to Apple Vision Pro and MacBooks? Here's What We Know

60% reliable12 mins

TSMC’s 2nm Breakthrough: What It Means for Your Next iPhone

84% reliable9 mins

2025 iPhone SE 4 to Feature Apple’s First Custom 5G Chip

65% reliable10 mins

iPhone 17 Expected to Launch With These 10 New Upgrades

67% reliable14 mins

Foldable iPads and Macs Are Coming, Leaks Reveal

58% reliable10 mins

Apple’s M5 iPad Pro Set to Launch Late 2025: What You Need to Know

62% reliable12 mins

Apple vs. Indonesia: A $1 Billion Offer to End the iPhone 16 Sales Ban

100% reliable9 mins

Pocket-Sized iPad? Apple's Foldable iPhone Might Unfold Like a Book

60% reliable8 mins

Top 10 Rare Apple Prototypes You've Never Seen

98% reliable22 mins
Apple

Apple

Microsoft

Microsoft

Google

Google

Samsung

Samsung

Meta

Meta

More stories

iPhone 17 Dummy Units Leaked in Hands-On Video

70% reliable9 mins

Shocking Survey: 73% of iPhone Owners Say AI Is 'Useless'

95% reliable13 mins

iPhone 16E: Features, Specs, Design, Release Date, and More

100% reliable20 mins

100+ Best Free Wallpapers for M4 MacBook Air

100% reliable110 mins

M4 MacBook Air: Pricing, Release Date, Design, Performance, Battery Life, and More

100% reliable12 mins

Apple Just Delayed Siri’s Smartest Feature—And It Might Never Arrive

68% reliable9 mins

Apple’s Foldable iPhone: Release Date, Design, Specs, Features, and More

64% reliable13 mins

Free Download: All iPhone 16E Stock Wallpapers in High Resolution

100% reliable14 mins

Top 100+ Free 4K Wallpapers for iPhone 16E

100% reliable85 mins

iPhone 16E Review: Great Performance, But Expect Some Trade-Offs

100% reliable10 mins

Free Download: Apple M4 MacBook Air Default Wallpapers

100% reliable13 mins

Apple’s M4 MacBook Air Just Got Faster, Smarter, and Cheaper—Here’s What’s New

100% reliable7 mins


More stories
Looking for the perfect wallpaper?
Explore thousands of free, high-quality wallpapers from Apple Scoop, specially crafted for your Apple devices.

Gradient

Apple

4K

HD

Landscape

Beach

Marble

Space

City

Pattern

Sunset

Ocean

Moon

Architecture

Quote




More wallpapers