×
Photo via The Washington PostNext

Here's Why Trump’s Push to Unlock Encrypted iPhones Won’t Work

100% reliable
10 mins
22.46K views
Apple
  • Trump is not happy with Apple—find out why they won’t unlock their iPhones.
  • Another encryption showdown... and Apple is holding its ground again.
  • This isn’t the first time Apple’s has said no to a request to break encryption—here’s the latest twist.

Apple Inc. is under the microscope today as former President Donald J. Trump urges the tech giant to assist the FBI in unlocking iPhones belonging to the individuals accused of attempting to assassinate him. Trump’s request reflects a common misunderstanding about encryption—a technology designed to protect user data, even from the manufacturer. So today, let's talk about encryption, and why it's impossible for Apple to comply with Trump's request.Encryption on iPhones protects user data—even Apple can’t access it without the devices passcode.Photo via PCMag // Encryption on iPhones protects user data—even Apple can’t access it without the devices passcode.

Trump Demands Apple’s Help

In recent months, there have been two failed assassination attempts on Donald Trump, the Republican nominee for United States President. Law enforcement have retrieved multiple phones belonging to the alleged perpetrators, but they’ve hit a roadblock—encryption. At a rally in North Carolina on Wednesday, Trump voiced his frustrations, urging Apple to step in.

They must get Apple to open the foreign apps, and they must get Apple to likewise open the six phones from the second lunatic.— Trump stated, according to Bloomberg

The phones in question belong to Thomas Matthew Crooks, who shot at Trump during a July rally, and Ryan Wesley Routh, apprehended after a shootout at Trump’s Florida golf club. Despite the FBI’s efforts, they have been unable to access the devices or the data within several encrypted apps.Pictured: Tim Cook (left) and Donald Trump (right). Former President Donald Trump is calling on Apple to unlock iPhones linked to recent assassination attempts.Photo via The New York Times // Pictured: Tim Cook (left) and Donald Trump (right). Former President Donald Trump is calling on Apple to unlock iPhones linked to recent assassination attempts.

Why Apple Can’t Comply: Encryption Explained

The former president's plea illustrates a widespread misconception. Many believe that because a device manufacturer, like Apple, creates their own hardware and software, they must be able to unlock encrypted data on request. However, this simply isn’t the case.

Encryption, by design, prevents any party—except the user with the passcode—from accessing the device's contents. Even Apple itself is locked out once encryption is applied.

Apple has been clear on its stance. According to a company statement:

End-to-end encrypted data can be decrypted only on your trusted devices where you’re signed in to your Apple Account. No one else can access your end-to-end encrypted data—not even Apple.— Apple Inc.

This ensures that all sensitive data on iPhones, such as messages on iMessage or calls on FaceTime, remains private unless the device’s owner provides the necessary access credentials. Without the passcode, not even Apple can bypass this encryption.Apple’s refusal to unlock encrypted devices has sparked a broader debate about privacy vs. security.Photo via CNET // Apple’s refusal to unlock encrypted devices has sparked a broader debate about privacy vs. security.


A Broader Debate: Security vs. Privacy

This is not the first time law enforcement has demanded a way around encryption. In the past, calls for a “backdoor” to access encrypted data have gained traction. Law enforcement agencies argue that such a feature is essential for cases involving terrorism, serious crime, and, in this case, attempted assassination.

But the risks are clear. Security experts warn that creating a backdoor for law enforcement also creates a vulnerability for hackers. In short, any backdoor accessible to law enforcement could be exploited by malicious actors, jeopardizing the privacy of millions of users worldwide.

Apple executives have consistently emphasized privacy as a core value of the company. As a result, the company has stood firm against government demands, despite intense pressure from law enforcement and political figures like Trump.

In response to previous government requests to unlock phones, Apple has made its position clear:

If encryption could be easily bypassed, it would defeat its very purpose. Privacy is a fundamental human right.— Apple Inc.

Historical Context: The Ongoing Struggle

This latest request from Trump is reminiscent of his earlier clashes with Apple during his presidency. In 2021, Trump criticized the company for refusing to unlock the iPhone of a Royal Saudi Air Force lieutenant accused of killing three U.S. sailors. Back then, Apple maintained its position, rejecting demands to create a backdoor for authorities.

Now, just a day after being briefed by the Office of the Director of National Intelligence on new threats from Iran, Trump’s request comes at a time of heightened political tension. Iran has reportedly targeted Trump and his administration officials following the assassination of Iranian general Qassem Soleimani in 2020. Despite these circumstances, Apple’s commitment to privacy remains unchanged.


The Takeaway: No Exceptions

Apple is unlikely to bend under pressure—whether from Trump or any other figure. The company has long maintained that it cannot and will not create tools that would undermine encryption, regardless of the circumstances.

As one industry commentator put it:

It’s all or nothing; nothing or all. There is no ‘one time only’ exception.

The debate between security and privacy is far from over, and with Apple refusing to alter its stance, Trump’s demand may fall on deaf ears.

Recommended by the editors:

Thank you for visiting Apple Scoop! As a dedicated independent news organization, we strive to deliver the latest updates and in-depth journalism on everything Apple. Have insights or thoughts to share? Drop a comment below—our team actively engages with and responds to our community. Return to the home page.

Published to Apple Scoop on 26th September, 2024.
Carlos Collins

Carlos Collins

Creative Director / Content Curator

Carlos is Apple Scoop’s Creative Director and Content Curator, specializing in visuals, HD wallpapers, and fun facts about Apple. With 6 years of experience in design and content curation, Carlos ensures every piece of content is visually engaging and aligns with the brand’s aesthetic. He also oversees the creation of trivia and engaging listicles that keep readers coming back for more.

Carlos' journalism More about Apple
Stories related to Apple

Price Hike Expected for iPhone 18 Pro

68% reliable8 mins

Why Did Apple Discontinue the iPod?

100% reliable9 mins

Spotify vs. Apple Music: Which Streaming Service Wins in 2024?

100% reliable12 mins

8 Reasons Why Apple Products Are So Expensive

100% reliable14 mins

Apple’s Marketing Secrets: 7 Strategies Behind Their Advertising Success

100% reliable18 mins

Apple Vision Pro: Low Sales and Low User Engagement Persists

71% reliable11 mins

iPhone 17 Air Rumored to Launch With These 8 New Features

67% reliable15 mins

Say Goodbye to Green Bubbles: What iOS 18.2 Means for Your iPhone

100% reliable12 mins

Is 5G Coming to Apple Vision Pro and MacBooks? Here's What We Know

60% reliable12 mins

TSMC’s 2nm Breakthrough: What It Means for Your Next iPhone

84% reliable9 mins

Apple’s 20th Anniversary Macintosh: What Went Wrong?

100% reliable11 mins

2025 iPhone SE 4 to Feature Apple’s First Custom 5G Chip

65% reliable10 mins

iPhone 17 Expected to Launch With These 10 New Upgrades

67% reliable14 mins

Foldable iPads and Macs Are Coming, Leaks Reveal

58% reliable10 mins

Apple’s Biggest Product Failures: Top 10 Design and Business Flops

100% reliable20 mins

Apple’s HomePod with a Screen: Rumors, Release Date, Leaks, and More

59% reliable13 mins

Why Are Democrats Abandoning Elon Musk's X (Twitter) App?

100% reliable16 mins

Who is John Sculley? Inside Apple’s Turbulent Decade

100% reliable10 mins

The Complete History of the Apple Newton: Apple's First Handheld Product

100% reliable10 mins

Two New Apple Products Are Coming, Rumors Say

61% reliable10 mins
Apple

Apple

Microsoft

Microsoft

Google

Google

Samsung

Samsung

Meta

Meta

More stories

Price Hike Expected for iPhone 18 Pro

68% reliable8 mins

Apple’s 2026 MacBook Pro: OLED Display With No Notch

61% reliable8 mins

Why Did Apple Discontinue the iPod?

100% reliable9 mins

Spotify vs. Apple Music: Which Streaming Service Wins in 2024?

100% reliable12 mins

8 Reasons Why Apple Products Are So Expensive

100% reliable14 mins

MacBook Air M4: Release Date, Rumors, Specs, Design, and More

64% reliable13 mins

Apple’s Marketing Secrets: 7 Strategies Behind Their Advertising Success

100% reliable18 mins

Apple Vision Pro: Low Sales and Low User Engagement Persists

71% reliable11 mins

iPhone 17 Air Rumored to Launch With These 8 New Features

67% reliable15 mins

Say Goodbye to Green Bubbles: What iOS 18.2 Means for Your iPhone

100% reliable12 mins

Is 5G Coming to Apple Vision Pro and MacBooks? Here's What We Know

60% reliable12 mins

TSMC’s 2nm Breakthrough: What It Means for Your Next iPhone

84% reliable9 mins


More stories
Looking for the perfect wallpaper?
Explore thousands of free, high-quality wallpapers from Apple Scoop, specially crafted for your Apple devices.

Gradient

Apple

4K

HD

Landscape

Beach

Marble

Space

City

Pattern

Sunset

Ocean

Moon

Architecture

Quote




More wallpapers